Murder Ballad MondayTwo Sisters / Wind and Rain
mbm-header

Comments

Two Sisters / Wind and Rain — 4 Comments

  1. And I just realized after reading the latest post on this song that my reaction exactly mirrors those your students tend to have, Pat. Which makes me very happy!

  2. This song is a bit more disturbing to me than the songs we’ve explored previously, and even a bit more disturbing than, say, some of the hard-core death metal murder ballads I’ve explored and may or may not enjoy on occasion. After a week of thinking about it, I’m still not sure exactly why, but it has something to do with trickery. The Clannad version and other similar to it feel like a trick. On me. You could hum along or dance along to this song for a long time without fulling realizing what you are partaking of, enjoying, and passing along. (Which is exactly what happened to me.)

    Not that I mind what I’m partaking of, enjoying, and passing along in this case, but it is a bit unsettling not to realize it until “too late,” so to speak. The same kind of unsettling feeling I might have, I suppose, if I had played a beautiful little song only to discover later that my instrument was made of some poor murdered girl’s finger bones. So, there you go.

    Interesting that you came to know this song through your wife singing it to your infant son, because it has a definite nursery rhyme feel to me — that particular kind of nursery rhyme in which something pretty horrific is being conveyed. It’s like a macabre toy.

    I like the Welch version because it’s sad and haunting. The Clannad version strikes me as creepy-crawly, dancing skeletony, jack-o-laterny, both the trick and the treat.

    And with that I may have just talked myself into liking it best…