Border Ballads: Bruce Springsteen as Corridista
<<<Back to page 3
Springsteenās Long Wind-up: What Came Before the Ghost
Those who know only the red, white & blue album cover of Born in the U.S.A. might find it odd or problematic to stack Bruce Springsteenās border songs next to that image. In fact, Springsteenās Born in the U.S.A, a huge commercial success, has more complexity in it than many notice or acknowledge. Itās easy to let the music dominate that album and miss the stories. And itās easy to assume the 1984 album cover is at odds with the nuance heard in The Ghost of Tom Joad. It isnāt. The man in āBorn in the U.S.Aā is more than just a cool rocking daddy. Heās a disaffected Vietnam Veteran. Thereās no jingoism in this song, though those who know only the chorus might think otherwise. It is true that the border songs on The Ghost of Tom Joad reveal Springsteenās social conscience, but they arenāt his first songs addressing the hardships of others, and they arenāt his first or only songs that acknowledge or include Hispanic characters.
āMary Queen of Arkansas,ā a song on his first album, Greetings from Asbury Park, NJ, ends with an idea that Springsteen explores in many songs on various albums: the notion of starting over and the dream of a new place. Thereās also the intriguing reference to ācontacts deep in Mexico,ā which returns with more complexity or at least more nuance on The Ghost of Tom Joad in āSinaloa Cowboysā (when Miguel and Louis hear about the men in Sinaloa looking for some hands), and in āBalboa Parkā (when we learn Spider grew up near the Zona Norte with hustlers and smugglers). Hereās the end of āMary Queen of Arkansasā:
Mary queen of Arkansas, your white skin is deceivin’
You wake and wait, ooh, to lie in bait and you almost got me believin’
But on your bed, Mary, I can see the shadow of a noose
Whoa, I don’t understand how you can hold me so tight and love me so damn loose
But I know a place where we can go, Mary
Where I can get a good job and start out all over again clean
Oh, I got contacts deep in Mexico where the servants have been seen
Springsteenās second album, The Wild, The Innocent, The E Street Shuffle, features a character named āSpanish Johnnyā in āIncident on 57th Street.ā Hereās a relevant passage from that song:
“Hey, Spanish Johnny, you want to make a little easy money tonight?”
And Johnny whispered, “Goodnight, it’s all tight, Jane
I’ll meet you tomorrow night on Lover’s Lane
We may find it out on the street tonight, baby
Or we may walk until the daylight, maybe”
Oh, goodnight, it’s all right, Jane
I’m gonna meet you tomorrow night on Lover’s Lane
In this song, as in others, we find the temptation of easy money (as we see later in āSinaloa Cowboysā and āBalboa Parkā) and the optimism associated with future plans ā that promise to āmeet tomorrow night on Loverās Lane.ā The promise of a better tomorrow appears and reappears in Springsteenās music. We hear it in āBorn to Runā in the same-titled album (āSomeday girl I don’t know when / We’re gonna get to that place /Ā Where we really wanna go / And we’ll walk in the sunā), in āThe Promised Landā on his fourth album (in which he also moves into a different landscape ā the Utah desert), and in āAcross the Border,ā in which the dream of a better future is central to the song.
Seven years before The Ghost of Tom Joad was released, Springsteen covered two of Woody Guthrieās songs on Folkways: A Vision Shared, A Tribute to Woody Guthrie and Leadbelly. Guthrie, of course, sang about Tom Joad in his Dust Bowl Ballads. That Springsteen was part of the tribute album underscores his commitment to the folk tradition of giving a voice to the oppressed. The Folkways album is a cohesive musical recognition of hardship and inequality. These are songs of empathy and defiance. Springsteenās contributions to the album ā covers of āI Aināt Got No Homeā and āVigilante Manā ā open a conversation he continues in his border songs on The Ghost of Tom Joad. Guthrieās āTom Joad,ā inspired, of course, by Steinbeck, features a confrontation between a deputy sheriff, Preacher Casey, and Tom Joad. Preacher Casey gets clubbed, as does the deputy. The vigilante presence in that song is felt also in the violence of āBalboa Park.ā Itās likely that vigilante tradition informs the stand-off between Carl and Bobby in āThe Line,ā though what happens between Carl and Bobby is more complicated. The us/them binary dissolves into something harder to parse.
Springsteenās commitment to the disenfranchised didnāt begin with his border songs, nor did it end with them. Ten years after The Ghost of Tom Joad was released, Springsteen released his third acoustic album, Devils & Dust, the album that features āMatamoras Banks.ā In his liner notes, Springsteen introduces that song with this explanation: āEach year many die crossing the deserts, mountains, and rivers of our southern border in search of a better life. Here I follow the journey backwards, from the body at the river bottom, to the man walking across the desert towards the banks of the Rio Grande.ā A year after Devils & Dust, Springsteen released We Shall Overcome: The Seeger Sessions, which features many of the songs folk singer and social activist Pete Seeger helped to popularize.
What we hear in the border songs on The Ghost of Tom Joad has roots in the Mexican corrido tradition and in the work of Woody Guthrie and the American folk tradition. Consider this passage from Woody Guthrieās āTom Joadā:
They stood on a mountain and they looked to the west,
And it looked like the promised land.
That bright green valley with a river running through,
There was work for every single hand, they thought,
There was work for every single hand.
That river, in some ways, is the same river we find in Springsteenās āThe River,ā and the same river we find later in Springsteenās āAcross the Border.ā āFor what are we / Without hope in our hearts,ā Springsteen asks in the last border song on The Ghost of Tom Joad. As grim as these songs are, they bear hope. Hope is why Miguel and Louis came to California, and why Louisa wants to cross the border. Hope may seem to get downgraded to survival in many corridos, but thatās not quite accurate. At the core of survival is hope, which is, at some point, irreducible. I felt it when I listened to The Ghost of Tom Joad after my grandma died. Itās in the art that comes after and out of trauma, and itās a part of every murder ballad. Itās somewhere in āBalboa Park,ā dark as that song is, and itās in the raw, strange voices of corridistas on both sides of the river.