A Walkin’ Chunk a Mean-Mad: Pretty Boy Floyd & Robin Hood
<<<Back to page 1
(Note: Since lyrics differ only slightly between the two, song quotes derive from both versions.)
Woody Guthrie – Pretty Boy Floyd
The Byrds – Pretty Boy Floyd
Like many folk songs, “Floyd” uses factual material as a springboard for fantasy, collecting anecdotes and ascribing motivations to its subject that are impossible to verify. As with other once historical, now mythic figures (including Sherwood’s merry archer), Floyd becomes – in Guthrie’s hands – less a man than a metaphor. The difference is this is no King Arthur or Honest Abe Lincoln, evoked from the mists of time or at least a previous century, but a man who lived and died within (then) recent memory. Guthrie’s choice to consciously mythologize him is thus risky and bold.
Only one episode in the song seems to have been invented from whole cloth, and Guthrie dispenses with it in the first three verses:
It was in the town of Shawnee
A Saturday afternoon
His wife beside him in his wagon
As into town they rode
There a deputy sheriff approached him
In a manner rather rude
Using vulgar words of anger
And his wife she overheard
Pretty Boy grabbed a log chain
And the deputy grabbed his gun
In the fight that followed
He laid that deputy down
(Guthrie)
Floyd was a suspect in at least five homicides prior to the Kansas City slayings. After the Massacre, a DOJ special agent and a retired sheriff-turned-mercenary both died at his hands or those of his accomplices while trying to apprehend him. While none of these killings seemed unnecessarily cruel or vicious to a public predisposed to give “Pretty Boy” the benefit of the doubt (and unlike other figures in the 30s crime wave, Floyd seems to have taken no pleasure in killing), Guthrie’s oddly Victorian account of a duel to defend the honor of his lady fair would seem to have no basis in fact – it merely serves to establish his (anti-) hero’s innocence from the start, the better to portray him as a victimized class warrior.
He ran through the trees and bushes
And lived a life of shame
Every crime in Oklahoma
Was added to his name
He ran through the trees and bushes
On the Canadian River shore
And many a starving farmer
Opened up his door
(Byrds)
The truth behind Floyd’s unraveling is comparatively prosaic if far more tragic. Convicted of a St. Louis payroll robbery in his early twenties, he served three years of a five-year prison sentence, during which time his wife divorced him. Paroled in 1929, he vowed to go straight, but lack of work, the failure of his family’s farm, and numerous brushes with the law left him feeling bitter and persecuted. In November, his beloved father was killed during a quarrel with a local shopkeeper, and when the shooter was acquitted (on grounds of self-defense), the already overwrought Floyd seems to have snapped. Soon after, his father’s killer disappeared (the son is widely believed to have avenged the father) and “Pretty Boy” (nicknamed for his boyish, innocent-looking face) returned to robbery – this time hitting banks in a spree so brazen it guaranteed he’d spend the rest of his life a wanted man.